Answers
FAQs: Uttering Threats Charges in Ontario
Uttering threats charges can be confusing and stressful. Here are answers to the most common questions we hear from clients and their families:
What counts as uttering threats in Ontario?+
Uttering threats under s. 264.1 means knowingly threatening to kill or seriously hurt someone, damage their property, or injure their animal. The law requires that your words would be taken as a genuine threat by a reasonable person. If your statements were out of anger or jest with no intent to intimidate, you have a defence.
Can I be charged for a text message or social media post?+
Yes. Courts treat texts, emails, Instagram, Snapchat, and social media posts the same as spoken threats. Digital evidence preserves exact words but lacks tone and context, which can be used in defence. Authentication and completeness are critical issues we examine.
Is saying something in anger enough for a criminal charge?+
It can be. But the Supreme Court recognized in R. v. Clemente that words spoken in jest or venting should not attract criminal liability. Whether an angry statement crosses the line depends on the full context. A single argument does not automatically make someone a criminal.
What if I was drunk when I said it?+
In some cases, significant intoxication may become relevant to whether the Crown can prove the required intent. Courts assess these arguments carefully and they depend heavily on the facts.
What are the penalties for uttering threats?+
Up to 5 years (indictable) for threats of bodily harm, or up to 2 years for threats to property or animals. A 10-year firearms prohibition applies on conviction. Many first-time cases resolve with lighter sentences, peace bonds, or diversion.
Can I get bail on a threats charge?+
Yes. Under R. v. Antic, judges start with a presumption of release. We prepare strong release plans, secure sureties if needed, and handle bail quickly—including weekends through Ontario WASH courts.
Can the complainant drop the charge?+
No. Once charges are laid, the matter is in the Crown's hands. Even if the complainant wants the case dropped, the Crown may proceed based on other evidence.
Can I contact the complainant if they contact me first?+
No. If a no-contact order is in place, you cannot communicate with the complainant under any circumstances, even if they initiate. Responding is a criminal offence. Document any contact and call your lawyer.
Will a conviction affect my immigration status or ability to travel?+
Potentially, yes. A conviction can result in inadmissibility under the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, restrict travel to the United States, and affect employment and professional licensing.
What if my account was hacked or someone else sent the message?+
That is a defence. If forensic evidence or proof of account vulnerability shows someone else sent the message, the charge may be dismissed. Authentication of digital evidence is crucial—the burden is on the Crown to prove the accused actually sent the communication.